(ETonline) Michael Lynche and Aaron Kelly wound up in the bottom two Wednesday night on “American Idol,” and one of them had to hit the road by the show’s end!

Seventeen-year-old Aaron was eliminated after taking a stab at Frank Sinatra‘s “Fly Me to the Moon” — and earning mixed reviews from the judges — the previous night.

“I’ve had a blast,” he told Ryan Seacrest, who asked the teen singer how old he felt now. “Still 17,” Aaron replied.

Also on the results show, this week’s celeb mentor Harry Connick Jr. performed.

Tune in to “American Idol” next week as the Top 4 sing songs of the cinema and receive mentoring from Jamie Foxx.